Senior Humanities
  • Daily Lessons
  • Course Overview
  • Resources
  • Senior Project
    • 2025 Award Finalists
    • 2024 Award Finalists
    • 2023 Award Finalists
    • 2019 Award Finalists
    • 2018 Award Finalists
    • Early Senior Theses and TED Talks
  • Honors

Peer Critique- Proofreading

2/29/2024

 
DUE DATES- ON TIME- HUMANITIES​​​​​​​​
  1. FINAL DRAFT THESIS.  DUE: Friday, 3/1, Midnight (digital copy). Google Classroom. I will have cookies for all who have turned it in on MONDAY!
​
DUE DATES- LATE (-10%)​​​​​
  1. Nothing right now...

Starter:
  1. How do you find small errors in your writing?
  2. What kind of errors do you typically make when writing?
    1. Spelling? 
    2. Grammar?
    3. Syntax?
    4. Punctuation?
    5. An endless list?
  3. How perfect does your writing need to be for the senior thesis do you think?

The Revision
Today you are going to be going over your partner’s paper with an extremely fine toothed comb. The twist is: you’re not really reading it. It’s proofreading time, where content has no place next to that misplaced comma. 

Use this list of marks to make your proofreading suggestions. These marks are fairly standard across the country. If you go into the writing lab next year, wherever that may be, they will likely use these marks (or something like them) when making proofreading suggestions to your paper. 

Using standard markings ensures that time spent proofreading is time spent proofreading and not deciphering the meaning of poorly drawn hieroglyphics in the margins. 

Directions:
Find your paper in the pile of printed out theses and hand it to your partner. Then, take a pen and start nitpicking. Look for punctuation errors, spelling errors, double spaces, quotation mark mistakes, capitalizations, numbers as words vs numbers, extra words, redundant points, run on sentences, etc… Use the handout to get the markings standardized. 

Peer Critiques- Citations and Works Cited

2/28/2024

 
DUE DATES- ON TIME- HUMANITIES​​​​​​​​
  1. FINAL DRAFT THESIS.  DUE: Friday, 3/1, Midnight (digital copy). Google Classroom. I will have cookies for all who have turned it in on MONDAY!
​
DUE DATES- LATE (-10%)​​​​​
  1. Nothing right now...

Starter:
First and foremost: share your draft with Lori and Grayson. We’re doing a proofreading task tomorrow that needs your paper printed, so get it to us so we can get ‘er done. 

How do you push yourself to focus on tedious tasks? Think about when you’re at work, when you’re here, when you have chores, basically anytime it’s monotonous yet requires attention. If you’ve never had to do…well, sweet summer child…
  1. How do you get through these moments successfully?
  2. What strategies do you use?

The Task
Just like the starter indicated above, today we will be going through citations, a top 5 crowd pleaser. You’re going to be following this handout for today’s task.

Practice
Go through the examples on the handout and indicate if they are done correctly or not. If not, suggest how to change them to be correct.

Partner 1
Send your paper to the person on your left. They will then use the find and replace function (command/control F) and put a parentheses “(“ into the box. This will highlight all the in text citations like lights on a christmas tree. Then, you’ll have to read each setup and citation to determine if they have done the punctuation correctly. Leave a comment or use suggesting mode to make changes so they can see where they made mistakes. 

Partner 2
Send your paper to the person on your right this time. They’re going to go through your bibliography. As the reviewer, you get to be absolutely ruthless. Go after every single punctuation error, indentation mistake, spelling question, anything that an expert nitpicker would find atrocious and bring to your attention. Leave a comment or use suggestion mode to make clear every little problem you find. 

The Return
Take your paper back. Look over your comments. Address them. Lots of these little mistakes happen without intention and are extremely difficult to find on your own, so thank your partners for dressing you down and laying bare all your faults. Better they be found now than when we’re grading them and get to take points off for each little mistake. 

Work Priorities for Today
  1. Fix your comments and address mistakes
  2. Keep polishing your paper to a fine sheen
  3. Bask in the existential dread of having 2 more short days until the deadline

Peer Critiques- Sentence Focus

2/27/2024

 
DUE DATES- ON TIME- HUMANITIES​​​​​​​
  1. ​​SPAM 3. DUE: Tuesday, 2/27, 3:30 PM. Box in Lori's room.
  2. FINAL DRAFT THESIS.  DUE: Friday, 3/1, Midnight (digital copy). Google Classroom. I will have cookies for all who have turned it in on MONDAY!
​
DUE DATES- LATE (-10%)​​​​​
  1. Nothing right now...

Announcements
  1. NO OFF CAMPUS WEDNESDAY. We will be here to run peer critiques on in-text citations and Works Cited section.
  2. THESIS IS DUE ON FRIDAY!  At MIDNIGHT!  
  3. NEXT WEEK- Action Project Week. Be ready to start working on your project again, to set yourself up for success in April and May.
  4. Check your absences...some of you are edging up there. Remember that it doesn't matter if they are excused, and that 3 unexcused tardies = 1 absence.

Sentence Focus and Writing Concisely

We’re going to go over the mechanics of active and passive voice as well as making writing more concise as a class. Use this handout to complete the task and for future reference. 

Peer Critiques for Today
You’re going to need to make a new document that you will share with your partner for today (whom you’ve been paired with before). Then, take a 3-4 paragraph chunk of your thesis and copy it into that document.

Sentence Revision
You’re going to go over every sentence of your partner’s writing. Every. Single. Sentence. Highlight the sentence and start a comment. Make a suggestion for revision based on focus, conciseness, or any other revision you’d deem necessary.

Now for the REAL work
You’re going to take that same fine toothed comb and apply it to your own writing. Go through your partner’s suggestions to get warmed up, then look at every sentence you wrote to see if it’s focused and concise. This will likely take the rest of class if not beyond.

Peer Critiques- Transitions

2/26/2024

 
DUE DATES- ON TIME- HUMANITIES​​​​​​​
  1. ​​SPAM 3. DUE: Tuesday, 2/27, 3:30 PM. Box in Lori's room.
  2. FINAL DRAFT THESIS.  DUE: Friday, 3/1, Midnight (digital copy). Google Classroom. I will have cookies for all who have turned it in on MONDAY!
​
DUE DATES- LATE (-10%)​​​​​
  1. Nothing right now...

Announcements
  1. NO OFF CAMPUS WEDNESDAY. We will be here to run peer critiques on in-text citations and Works Cited section.
  2. THESIS IS DUE ON FRIDAY!  At MIDNIGHT!  
  3. NEXT WEEK- Action Project Week. Be ready to start working on your project again, to set yourself up for success in April and May.
  4. Check your absences...some of you are edging up there. Remember that it doesn't matter if they are excused, and that 3 unexcused tardies = 1 absence.

Starter
  1. On a scale of 1-4 (1 = confidence is underground it’s so low, 4 = supremely confident), how confident are you in your transitions in this thesis right now? 
  2. When are transitions easy to write? When are they difficult?

Transition Peer Critique
Trade papers with your assigned partner. 
  1. For each transition (looking at the last sentence of one paragraph and the first sentence of the next)
    1. Highlight any mirrored language (words/phrases that are the same or very similar)
    2. Highlight in a different color transitional phrases (see the list from the handout on your table)
  2. Choose the two WORST transitions. In a comment on the side of the paper, rewrite them using mirrored language, transitional phrases, or both.
  3. When you get your paper back, review the transitions and the highlights. If your transitions are missing mirrored language AND transitional phrases, rewrite them to include at least one of these!  Think carefully about logical connections, and maintaining accurate topic sentences. 

Revision Work Time 
  1. Revise all transitions
  2. Revise all the other things you need to revise!

Peer Critiques- Setting Up Quotes

2/23/2024

 
DUE DATES- ON TIME- HUMANITIES​​​​​​​
  1. ​​SPAM 3. DUE: Tuesday, 2/27, 3:30 PM. Box in Lori's room.
  2. FINAL DRAFT THESIS.  DUE: Friday, 3/1, Midnight (digital copy).  Hard copy for AM Pod due Monday, 3/4 at the start of class. 
​
DUE DATES- LATE (-10%)​​​​​
  1. Thesis Rough Draft. LAST DAY TO TURN IN: Friday 2/23, Start of Class. Google Classroom.

Boy there sure are a lot of callbacks to last season in this show, almost like the glory days are behind us. At least there aren’t any guest stars making appearances or I’d be worried they’re totally out of ideas. 

Setting Up Quotes Callback
You may remember from way back in season one a little task called setting up quotes. You’re not imagining things, this doc is slightly different than last time. Today, you’re going to delve into the intricacies of setting up quotes with a partner.

Peer Critique Setting up Quotes
Today, you need to once again share your thesis (or a copy of it) with your partner. They are going to be trawling through all your quotations to see how you set them up. Follow the handout for specifics, but as always, here’s the gist:

Command+F
Have you used the find and replace function in Google Docs yet? You’re about to become intimately familiar. Use Command/Control + F and put a quotation mark (“) in the textbox. This will highlight where every single direct quote is hiding. 

Step 1: The Hunt
Leave a comment on each quote setup indicating what type of setup it is. Don’t hit comment just yet.

Step 2: The Kill
On that same comment, add a “yes” if their punctuation is correct for said quote, a “no” if not. 

Step 3: Signal Phrases
Now for the new part. Highlight out the signal phrase they used in their setup. Look at setting up quotes if you need more context.

Step 4: Safe Harbor
Return to your paper with what should be a seemingly impossible wall of comments on the right. Go through them and take note of the setups you used. Make a tally if you feel so inclined. Now, what are you going to do to improve your setups?
  1. Do you need to vary your setups more?
  2. Are you missing signal phrases?
  3. What about the punctuation? Need to do some sleuthing to find out what’s wrong?

Peer Critiques- Part 3 Analysis

2/22/2024

 
DUE DATES- ON TIME- HUMANITIES​​​​​​​
  1. ​​SPAM 3. DUE: Tuesday, 2/27, 3:30 PM. Box in Lori's room.
  2. FINAL DRAFT THESIS.  DUE: Friday, 3/1, Midnight (digital copy).  Hard copy for AM Pod due Monday, 3/4 at the start of class. 
​
DUE DATES- LATE (-10%)​​​​​
  1. Thesis Rough Draft. LAST DAY TO TURN IN: Friday 2/23, Start of Class. Google Classroom.

Starter n+1: Another Setup Task
Go and find your partner for today. This time, you should be paired with someone in the same ballpark as your topic (i.e. science with science). Share your thesis (or a copy) with your partner. Or if you want a paper copy for highlighting, first of all tell us, send it to Lori or Grayson.
​
Analysis Framework Returns
I told you you’d see this again… even if I am in control and can make it a self fulfilling prophecy. Remember long long ago to last week when we did an analysis framework? Good.

Peer Review with Analysis Framework
You will be following this handout with your partner. You will need a few highlighting colors. 

Step 1: A Highlight of your Paper
Go through their part 3 and highlight the elements of their analysis. Use the handout for color recommendations. You’re going to need 5-6 colors. 

Step 2: Editor’s Commentary
Now, once you’ve made their paper good and colorful, you’re going to need to give some feedback notes. First up is the general feedback. Overall, what do they need to do? Done well? Etc? See the handout for sentence starters to get you going. 

Step 3: Specific Suggestions
Keep them commenting fingers warmed up, you’ve got more to write. Next up, you need 2 comments for specific suggestions to their paper. No rhetorical questions here.

Step 4: Analysis Suggestions
One more round of comments. You need to write 2 comments about their analysis sections. Luckily, you have colored this up like a rainbow. What do they need to add? What do they need to change? More context? More why sentences? 

Step 5: Pearl Clutching
Return your colorful mess to its original author. Let them really drink in just how messy their hard work looks. Now, read over their comments, look around the highlights, and come up some actionable steps to be done for your writing. See handout for details.

Step 6: Get Workin’
Use your suggestions and actionable steps to get revising.

​

Peer Critique- Part 2

2/21/2024

 
DUE DATES- ON TIME- HUMANITIES​​​​​​​
  1. ​​SPAM 3. DUE: Tuesday, 2/27, 3:30 PM. Box in Lori's room.
  2. FINAL DRAFT THESIS.  DUE: Friday, 3/1, Midnight (digital copy).  Hard copy for AM Pod due Monday, 3/4 at the start of class. 
​
DUE DATES- LATE (-10%)​​​​​
  1. Thesis Rough Draft. LAST DAY TO TURN IN: Friday 2/23, Start of Class. Google Classroom.

Starter - Divide to Conquer
Pull up your thesis document and a blank document. Copy and paste your section 2 into that new document. Share that new document with your partner below. 
​
Peer Critiques for Background Information
Go and sit with your partner. With any luck, they’ll have absolutely no clue what your topic is about. This is good. You want a blank slate to see what you, the expert, are overlooking as obvious.

Your Task
Follow directions on this handout. Write notes on the same paper that you are reading this morning for your partner. 

Step 1: The Read.
Read their background, make some notes. Refer to the handout for specifics here. 

Step 2: The connection.
When you get to step 2, have your partner copy paste their intro section into your shared document. Then, continue to give them notes on that sheet. Again, refer to the handout for specific notes.

Step 3: The Return.
Take a gander at your partner’s notes. Then, add to this document with the next steps you need to follow as described in the handout. 

Back to Work
You’ve got some editing to do.  Revision Priorities for today…
  1. Revise Part 2 of your thesis
  2. Turn your attention to Part 3- add evidence, expand analysis (remember what, why, connections!), 
  3. Add transitions/citations
  4. Need a brain break? Go to the MLA Formatting Checklist (because almost no-one had this right on their drafts)

Peer Critique- Introduction

2/20/2024

 
DUE DATES- ON TIME- HUMANITIES​​​​​​​
  1. ​​SPAM 3. DUE: Tuesday, 2/27, 3:30 PM. Box in Lori's room.
  2. FINAL DRAFT THESIS.  DUE: Friday, 3/1, Midnight (digital copy).  Hard copy for AM Pod due Monday, 3/4 at the start of class. 
​
DUE DATES- LATE (-10%)​​​​​
  1. Thesis Rough Draft. LAST DAY TO TURN IN: Friday 2/23, Start of Class. Google Classroom.

Starter- Thesis Statement + Research Question
On your draft, highlight your research question and thesis statement. Pass to your left. For the one you receive, in a comment on their draft, write the following. 
  1. Look at their research question. In a comment, write down the different things they will need to answer to fully answer this question.
  2. Look at their thesis statement. Now, look back at their question.  Do they answer ALL the parts of their question in their thesis?  In your comment, make note of any mismatches between their thesis statement and their research question.
  3. In a SECOND comment on their thesis statement, write what you predict will be in their arguments based on their thesis statement. Make sure to address what types of arguments they will need to make (what will they need to prove?), what kind of evidence they will need to prove their thesis, and what potential counter-arguments there are to the argument they are trying to make (what would disprove their thesis?).

Part 1 Peer Critiques
Remind of critique norms- specific, helpful, and kind. List of critique qualities on the board. 

Get with your assigned groups. Trade papers (digitally, or have Lori print Part 1 of their paper). For each person:
  1. Read part 1.
  2. Discuss their hook- 
    1. What is it?
    2. Does it effectively get the reader interested? Why/why not?
    3. How could they make it better?
    4. If you think it’s effective, WRITE IT ON THE BOARD with their name next to it!
  3. Answer as a group, verbally: 
    1. After reading this introduction, why should we care about this topic?
    2. What would make you care more, or understand better why it is important?
  4. Repeat for each group member
  5. To move into independent revision time, show Lori or Grayson a list of revisions you want to make to your question, thesis statement, and/or Part 1.

Revision Time!

  1. Start with rewriting, re-organizing, expanding
  2. Add evidence
  3. Make connections to thesis statement

Peer Critique- Part 1

2/16/2024

 
DUE DATES- ON TIME- HUMANITIES​​​​​​​
  1. ​​SPAM 2. DUE: Tuesday, 2/27, 3:30 PM. Box in Lori's room.
  2. FINAL DRAFT THESIS.  DUE: Friday, 3/1, Midnight (digital copy).  Hard copy for AM Pod due Monday, 3/4 at the start of class. 
​
DUE DATES- LATE (-10%)​​​​​
  1. SPAM 2. LAST DAY TO TURN IN: Monday 2/19, 3:30 PM. Box in Lori's room, can email reflection.
  2. Thesis Rough Draft. LAST DAY TO TURN IN: Friday 2/23, Start of Class. Google Classroom.

Announcements:
  1. WEDNESDAYS will be ON CAMPUS for the next two weeks, so we can cram in more revision lessons.  AM Pod, you need to be here periods 1 and 2. PM Pod, you need to be here periods 3 and 4.
  2. SPAM 3 handouts are due Tuesday, 2/27

Starter Whatever
  1. Why do we do peer critiques?  List at least 3-5 reasons why. 
  2. What makes peer critique useful?  When are they not useful?
  3. What does it take from you as a reader to offer a useful critique?

Rubric Analysis
  1. Read through the rubric that we will use to grade your senior thesis. 
  2. For each bullet point: circle if you are confident in this as it stands right now, star if it needs revision but you are confident in your ability to do it, square if you know it needs improvement but you’re not sure how to do this.
  3. Review Thesis Revision handout, explain structure of the next few weeks, review schedule
  4. Set expectation- you will be engaging in critique EVERY DAY. You will probably also have to spend time outside of class to refine this.  I want this to be the BEST THING you have ever written. This takes time, energy, and focus!

Day 1 Critique- Full Read Through
Get with your partner. You are going to do a full read-through of their senior thesis. On their paper, I want you to mark the following things with comments:
  1. Underline or highlight their thesis statement
  2. ? Where you are confused or lost. Leave comments on at least 2 of these places explaining why you are lost, and how they might re-orient you.
  3. + Where there is insight, a powerful connection, or a point that you think is particularly strong.  Leave detailed comments on at least 2 of these that say what you like about it, and why it’s effective for you as a reader.
  4. At the end of their thesis, leave two substantive comments of at least 3 sentences each. Refer back to the rubric to help guide your comments!
    1. Strengths- What are the major strengths of this thesis?  What are they doing well?  Be specific about where this shows up and why you think it’s strong. 
    2. Revisions- What are at least two major revisions that they should focus on?  Why/how would these improve the paper?  Only ONE of these can be from the last rubric category!

Work Time
  1. Make sure you have SPAM 3 scheduled for next week, and that you've shared your draft with your advisor
  2. Start revising!

Abstract, Title Page, FINISH ALL THE THINGS!

2/15/2024

 
DUE DATES- ON TIME- HUMANITIES​​​​​​​
  1. Thesis Rough Draft. DUE: Friday 2/16, Start of Class. Google Classroom.​​
​
DUE DATES- LATE (-10%)​​​​​
  1. SPAM 2. LAST DAY TO TURN IN: Monday 2/19, 3:30 PM. Box in Lori's room, can email reflection.

Announcements:
  1. WEDNESDAY- Off Campus Work Day. Meet at the Durango Public Library or Smiley Building by 9:30, plan on working until 12.
  2. SPAM 3 handouts are due Friday, 2/23
  3. First Drafts are due TOMORROW before class

​Starter 20-whatever:  SPAM 3 EMAIL- SEND THAT SUCKER NOW
  1. Senior Project Advisor Letter 3:  This letter is a guide to asking for your final meeting, focusing on feedback to your thesis draft.
  2. Meetings need to happen NEXT WEEK.  Earlier is better!
  3. SPAM Form 3:  Make sure you bring this to SPAM 3!  It will guide your conversation about your rough draft!

Title Page and Abstract
Follow the example on these slides to create your title page. This is a formality for academic writing and needs to be done in the “because I said so” mold. As for the Abstract, follow that sheet. The gist is that an abstract is almost like a summary that addresses your question, what the research is, why it’s important, and what the conclusion is. It’s the executive summary, the spark notes if you will. If you’re wondering what the difference between an abstract and an intro is, you're asking the wrong question. 

Work Priorities, by Start of Class Friday:
  1. Rough Draft of Thesis is ready to be read, even if it’s not perfect. This includes:
    1. A properly formatted title page and abstract
    2. A full works cited in MLA format
    3. The rest in MLA format (see the handy dandy checklist on Google Classroom)
    4. 10+ pages of writing (15+ for honors)
    5. Lots of juicy evidence with fair trade citations
    6. Plenty of tenderizing analysis to make said evidence even more succulent 
  2. SPAM 3 is sent, and your draft (even if incomplete) has been shared with your SPA
  3. The Rough Draft is TURNED IN to Google Classroom!
<<Previous

    Lori's Blog

    Lesson plans posted daily. Come here to see what you missed, find instructions, etc.

    Archives

    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    March 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Daily Lessons
  • Course Overview
  • Resources
  • Senior Project
    • 2025 Award Finalists
    • 2024 Award Finalists
    • 2023 Award Finalists
    • 2019 Award Finalists
    • 2018 Award Finalists
    • Early Senior Theses and TED Talks
  • Honors